Home/Blogs/Opinion

Top 5 Fantasy Tail Plugs That Bring Out Your Wild Side

Oct 22, 2025
  • 0 Collect
  • 2 Like
  • 390 Read
  • Report
Cover Image

Butt plugs. Tails. Two completely different things. Though very different, very awesome. Someone out there had the genius idea of combining these two things to create a butt plug tail.

The talented sex toy designers over at Butt Plug Tails took this idea and really ran off with it. These toys are butt plugs that feature hair coming out of the end of it, most of them depicting animal hair, but not exclusively.

I talked to a BUNCH of my friends to compile a list of the top five best butt plug tails. These aren't in any particular order, but I am sharing my favs from different categories.

And quick note! Some people think that these are for furries, when that isn't really the case. Furries could definitely use these, but so could anyone else. If you're into pet play or wanna try something new and kinky, then go for it! Especially with Halloween coming up. You could be a sexy fox in the streets and a plugged up one in the sheets.

Best Fox Tail Butt Plug

Detailed evaluation

The Fox Tail with Metal Butt Plug here is a fine piece of work. It features a petite, 2.5 inch plug. There's definitely a bit of contrast between the size of the plug itself with the sheer length of hair. There's a LOT of hair on this toy.

I also really appreciate the detail in the hair itself. There are some dark spots that really pop out and add that extra touch of realism. This is definitely a tier above Spirit Halloween quality! While there are more fox tail offerings out there, this one just spoke to me in terms of how realistic and high-quality it looks.

Best Bunny Tail Butt Plug

Detailed evaluation

Wanna hop on that D? Fulfill your bouncy fantasies with the Cottontails Silicone Bunny Tail Butt Plug. This is a very beginner-friendly butt plug. The soft, silicone surface is comfortable. You won't get tired of having this plug up inside of you.

Bunny Tail Butt Plugs are usually the simplest type of tail butt plugs. I just love how this one is so full of personality! The plug's shape is just perfect for people looking to either walk around with this toy inside of them or for those seeking stimulation.

Best Pony Tail Butt Plug

Detailed evaluation

The Blonde Pony Tail Metal Anal Plug is a fine piece of work. Just look at how long the hair is, and how beautiful the color looks! The plug itself is also a lot more straightforward. It's a standard design with 3 inches of insertable length. The cutest bow ever can be found at the end of the braid.

Pony tail butt plugs can either come braided or unbraided. It's nice to see how this one comes braided. It saves you some work! But it's still high-quality enough to brush and braid up again.

Best Rainbow Tail Butt Plug

Detailed evaluation

The Unicorn Rainbow Tail Silicone Plug has such a beautiful color to it. Again, it's a pretty standard plug design with 3.5 inches of insertable length. The real standout here is the color. Just look at how gorgeous it is, especially with that braid tying everything together.

Rainbow tail butt plugs are great for showing off pride! If you're a part of the gay kinky community, then this type of toy is a gem that you need to have.

Best Unicorn Tail Butt Plug

Detailed evaluation

The Unicorn Tail Anal Plug is probably my fav unicorn butt plug. Unicorn tail plugs are usually so much more colorful than other tail plugs. The butt plug itself on this toy features a crazy design!

The Plug for Plugs

So, what do you think? Are you able to handle these amazing tail butt plugs?

Head on over to Butt Plug Tails to get one of these amazing pieces of sex toy art! Or browse around and find something that suits your own personality. The possibilities are endless.