Home/Reviews/Penis Toys

The New York Toy Collective Archer Packer Review: This is a Winner!

Oct 25, 2025
  • 0 Collect
  • 2 Like
  • 382 Read
  • Report
Cover Image

Overall Rating

4.0
5.0
4.3
5.0
  • Overall rating is based on Design, Sensory Quality, Ease of Use, and Ease of Cleaning. Price and Noise are shown for reference only.

Review Disclosure: The products reviewed on ToyChats come from items we purchase ourselves and those sponsored by manufacturers. We do not accept paid reviews from brands, nor do we interfere with users’ genuine opinions of the products. Our sole concern is whether the reviews are authentic, trustworthy, and well-reasoned.

My verdict

Like me, Archer is versatile, able to assume many roles! The fact that it’s not hyper-realistic is not a big drawback, as it looks incredible under clothing. Archer creates a mouthwatering bulge under most types of undergarments, which is his job description! This packer has become a staple of my wardrobe.

Pros

Balances ball size with bulge for a comfortable wear.
Body-safe silicone.
Easy to clean and sanitize.
Respectable price point.

Cons

Low detailing makes it suited only for use under clothes.

Purchase Now from Exclusive Deals

ToyChats may use affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our reviews are based on real user experiences and remain independent of affiliate partnerships.

Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate

My first look at the Archer packer by the NY Toy Collective was it being rocked by a major, now-retired, transmasc porn star. Prior to this discovery, I was vaguely aware that transmasc folks "pack," but I'd never considered it for myself. In fact, I learned that packing is not just for transmasc people, and is performed by lots of people, including those identifying as FTM, genderqueer, gender-expansive, and even cisgender, and for lots of reasons!

Seeing someone I looked up to working it so well awakened something inside me. I couldn't stop thinking about how it would look to have a bulge in my pants - and, more importantly, how it would feel. After a little bit of hemming and hawing (this was, in fact, one of the first concrete steps I took to further explore my gender identity), I purchased one and eagerly awaited its delivery. And that was over four years ago! Today, and dozens of packers later, the Archer is still one of my favorites!

Archer is produced and sold by the New York Toy Collective, a company which bills itself as “[creating] high-quality intimacy toys and products for all forms of gender affirmation.” They sell packers, STP (stand-to-pee) items, pumps, binders, accessories, and sundry. The brand is focused on sex-positivity which, as you may have surmised, is a cause for which I care greatly. Their prices are standard for hand-poured silicone, and a “Whoops” section is available for those who don’t mind cosmetic imperfects in exchange for a discount price.

Design

The toy comes in two sizes, large and small, and is available in four skin tones and four "whimsical" colors.

I purchased a large Archer in the "cashew" color tone. The color is uniform throughout, so it is not hyper-realistic. It definitely looks like silicone against my skin. The head is moderately detailed, the shaft is mildly detailed, and the balls are moderately detailed, with folds and wrinkles and a realistic seam in the center. The head and shaft are more detailed on the underside; I found the area of the frenulum to be quite detailed, as well as the center vein along the bottom. The top of the head and shaft are smooth in a way that the eye tends to "snag" on.

I find that the Archer is just the right size for me as a 5'5" person. I like that the length and thickness of the balls and base give a realistic bulge shape when worn.

Quality

This is solid silicone with good pour quality. Any bubbles or small defects that do not effect the item's integrity are marked as lower-priced "Whoops" pours, which is a nice way to provide a slight discount to folks who can't afford a full price prosthetic.

Experience

Despite lacking detail, the packer profile looks GREAT beneath underwear - and honestly, that's the most important part. The flat back nestles against the pubic mons and creates a pleasing, alluring bulge. I have found that the large Archer hits the sweet spot, performing equally well in jockstraps, women's thongs, and men's briefs. The Archer is also comfortable, even when jammed into regular underwear. I have worn it out and found it stays in place in regular snug panties. I did find that on warm days the silicone sticks to and pulls on my pubes. This problem can be fixed with a packing pouch, which, just as it sounds, is a fabric pouch used to hold a packer in place. NYTC sells a magnetic-closure packing pouch - and while I wish the magnets were stronger, it does the job of keeping the packer in one place and protecting my skin from longer wear.

Performance

I have now been using this packer for over four years with exactly zero change in it! No tears, discoloration, rips, etc. That is very impressive to me. This seems to be a prosthetic built to withstand heavy wear.

Materials and care

The Archer is a hand-poured, soft silicone packer. The toy is not listed as being platinum-cured silicone, so caution should be used when storing it so as to ensure it doesn't come into contact with other toys. Even non-platinum-cured silicone is a wonderful material, though: lightweight, hypoallergenic, and easy to sterilize. I usually just wash it with soap and hot water.

Packaging

It's been so long since I purchased this item that I frankly have no memory of the unboxing experience; I expect it was sanitary and inoffensive. :)

Price

Yes, it's worth the price. It's often tempting to spend less on something that is meant to be worn under clothes, however, I have found the Archer to be comfortable, appealing, and robust where many packers have failed one of those points!

Purchase Now from Exclusive Deals

ToyChats may use affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Our reviews are based on real user experiences and remain independent of affiliate partnerships.

Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Caramel
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Vanilla
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate
New York Toy Collective
Archer Silicone Packer by New York Toy Collective - Chocolate